Anyone ever used Decluttr.com?

I have. I don't advise it. I had a stack of cd's I no longer wanted and sent them to decluttr. I had two orders that totaled $10.81 and $7.48 - not a fortune - but a decent little chunk that was coming into my PayPal.

I received notice that the order for $10.81 was processed and I only received $2.56 because they rejected 9 of my 14 items.

Here's the thing that honks me off - the 9 they rejected, they don't ship back to you. I didn't check it (okay, shame on me) but any item they reject, they "cannot return to the seller", which means they got 9 free cd's from just me. Not to mention, I feel like they owe me $8.

All the rejections were not for the discs being beat up - they were "wrong barcode" - which is stupid because I scanned every barcode with the app that they designed!

Seriously, I feel like I would have been better off just giving them away on Facebook or throwing them in the trash.

That would seriously tick me off as well.
I don't mind giving cds away to individuals but I'm not going to give them away to any business for free.  Total B.S.

I felt just as burned by CD trading site LaLa when they went MP3 sales and trading dried up.  I was out around 13-15 CDs that I would never receive a disc in return or download either.  Since then, I have been hesitant to swap CDs through any site.  I've also not found a lot that I wanted that way.

Glad to hear I'm not reacting unreasonably. I wouldn't mind the rejection so much if I got my stuff back. I think from now on when I can't sell something, I'm just gonna give it to Goodwill or something.